Unpopular Opinion: Human Design, Gene Keys & Astrology Are Consuming Your Power
Esoteric systems, such as Human Design, Gene Keys, numerology and even Astrology are the frameworks you arrive in when unconscious to your own power. It’s your default mode when living on autopilot. When you transcend these systems, you fully embody your true potency.
Humans are more magnetic and powerful than any esoteric system. You are sovereign af. No modality defines you unless you hand over your authority to it OR you’re so deep on autopilot you’re oblivious to the energies moving within and around you.

Let me explain. These systems are used for self-discovery, deep reflection of ‘who am I?’ that are genuinely useful for expanding your view of what’s possible, getting into alignment and finding your orientation in the world. I honor these systems completely for these reasons.
But every system has an edge. And at the outer edges of these frameworks exists a ceiling – one that, if you’re not astute to it, will box you in exactly the same way any label in society ever has – an expectation on who you ‘be.’ Emphasis on expectation. These systems “enlighten” you to how you’re “expected” aka “designed” to interact and express in the world. So while it’s a step towards deeper enlightenment it eventually can start to run the show.
I’ve watched people fawn over their type, zodiac, gate, key or whatever as a way of proclaiming why they are more special than someone else, or used as an excuse to not take action, or to leverage their fears, or to not take a leap or put something forth or worse: they feel inadequate. Yes, these are all shadow expressions. HD people would refer to these as “not-self” expressions. GK call these “shadow,” in astrology it’s “lower octave” and in numerology it’s “challenge number.” (please don’t crucify me if this isn’t exact – I know experts in each system use slightly different terminology for the dark/shadow expression)
Years ago I had a conversation with someone close to me who had just had a Human Design reading. They told me they were a Projector and that they are actually the Seer of society, the most superior of all and that they aren’t meant to have an emotional human experience (paraphrasing here, but this was the core takeaway). Bananas right? Especially that last bit. (I totally know you might be thinking they just went to an undereducated chart reader but I think this convo exemplifies my point – the practitioner is well established in the HD community.) So instead of using this information for self-reflection and evolution, they weaponized it. At the time I was doing deep work with a powerful shaman who just happened to be bringing through a major Human Design transmission. I was wading through a lot of spiritual information and was also confronted with this ideology of superiority from that newly minted projector. I brought it up to my shaman and anticipated some kind of profound response – even anticipating being told I needed to do more healing so I could hold space for this person. But instead, she laughed…hysterically. The kind of laugh that says more than any explanation could.
My shaman is a Manifesting Generator. She is an actual Seer and guides people – she is an embodiment of what this person was trying to claim from a chart reading. I get it, it’s easy for us to distort these systems and honestly, all of us are looking for relief and desire to feel extraordinary. Now, I’m sure if you’re well versed in HD you’ll agree what the projector said is accurate (even if slightly misunderstood or out of context) or perhaps defend, pointing out they are expressing their “not-self.” But stop, I refuse to give my power to yet another hierarchy that’s just using different language (adding that HD was founded by a male none-the-less who is also, gasp, a Projector).
Yes, spiritual modalities can crack open real insight and awareness. But these insights are not the same as the divinity you incarnated with that aligns directly to God and your higher self. A chart doesn’t get the final say over your power, perspective or lived experience.
These modalities are just that – inferior tools compared to our own divine spirit that lives within each of us. They are tools to serve our humanness and magnetism not outrank it.
I say this as a Spiritual Guide who has dived into many of these such as HD, GK, numerology and astrology specifically. And every time, I circle around how we humans are constantly being asked to hand over our sovereignty or perspective or to adopt an energy that is un-alive or un-lived within us to begin with. Or worse, I can clearly see and feel the tension of dogma being served up as enlightenment (sorry – not sorry HD! Love HD but man, there’s some strong dogma in there depending on interpretation or how it’s embodied).
I’m highlighting cosmology specifically because it is the inspiration, backbone or incorporated in many of the systems I have personally studied or followed. There are other esoteric systems that do not incorporate cosmology such as Enneagram and Runic Divination. Although after further research it seems that even these have a crossover to cosmology but rooted in sacred geometry or cosmic law.
Once you start to understand that we all have access to all the things – the field, our divinity, intuition, higher perspective, authenticity and more – the need for these tools drastically decreases. This is a massive concept to sit with and really integrate: none of this was ever gatekept behind a chart. These systems don’t unlock your intuition because you already have access to it. They also don’t automatically put you into your highest alignment because alignment comes from the heart. These systems are great for pointing you towards what’s already yours but were never the source OF it. For some (many??) it can be a great starting place to get into alignment and/or expand their spiritual perspective – which is ultimately the goal.
People limit themselves to their type, zodiac sign, key, number – because it feels safer and frankly more expansive to give their power to these systems verses the inherited or conditioned roles of society. I totally get that, and honestly prefer that, compared to running on unconscious autopilot. Most non-spiritually curious people are living in the default systems they arrive to earth with. There’s a greater influence of planet placements and chart blueprints which are the primary drivers in these people’s lives. It’s like Carl Jung said, “Until you make the unconscious, conscious, it will direct your life and you will call it fate.”
But every single one of us has the capacity to transcend all systems.
Let me be clear: I feel deeply connected to the stars and the planets. The human body is made up of 97% stardust after all (and omg there is so much power in that alone!). I feel their influence and communicate with their energies. But what I don’t hand over is my power, choice, or divine alignment (which does require immense discretion). My relationship with the cosmos is a collaborative union, not a chain of command or expectation of how I’m to show up and produce. The universe likes surprises after all!
Look no further than modern physics. The universe runs on calculation – the same equations and orbits playing out exactly as predicted, again and again. That’s the framework I’d put most esoteric systems into as well: precise, patterned, predictable. But zoom into the quantum level and electrons stop playing by those rules. They unpredictably jump between energy states. The universe itself doesn’t decide until the moment it happens. I like to think the jump is where the spark lives – our free will and power – the part that was never constrained by calculation to begin with.
And this isn’t just happening out in the stars – it’s happening inside you too. Every atom in your body is doing the same thing, right now, at the cellular level. It’s these same unpredictable quantum jumps that power the process of feeling awake, capable or alive. No part of you was ever fully predetermined down to the smallest atom in your body. Michael Pollan, drawing on his conversations with neuroscientist Mark Solms, put it this way: “Consciousness is born of uncertainty. In a completely predictable world, we wouldn’t need it, and the light of consciousness would probably blink out.” These systems and frameworks are predictable by nature. But they can’t determine all of you — because you’re conscious, and consciousness itself is unpredictable by definition. We always have access to our power within and the freedom to leap into the unknown on our own terms.
I optimize with the energy of the cosmos in the same way you catch an ocean current – I move with or outside of and leverage it. But just like in a riptide, if it’s pulling me somewhere I didn’t choose or feels unaligned (discretion again people!) I swim out. The key is to always swim parallel to shore if you want out of the current. Please realize you get to make these same choices too.
That’s the difference between connection/collaboration and containment. You can feel the pull of the planets and refuse to let a placement be the ceiling on what you build and bring forth into the world or who you become / want to be. YOU are the trailblazer, YOU are a spirit that is more ancient and powerful than the cosmos in the sky.
These modalities were put in place to support the human journey and experience – not define it.
The moment you make a choice because a modality told you it’s how you should feel or act, and that choice goes against what actually feels aligned in your soul (discretion ya’ll!) – the entire system has failed you right there. Your humanness, your divine spirit, was compromised for a label or stunted by the system’s limits.
Your spirit was never meant to live inside a box. It was always intended to be free. It carries a power older than the galaxies we see today or from ancient scrolls. Stop giving your power away to another cage. Use it to expand or support your foundation until you can fully fly with integrity, discernment and your own inner compass.
I recently purchased my own copy of the Gene Keys book instead of borrowing from the library again. That’s how much I enjoy reading and expanding within these systems’ limits. But still, I never lose sight that my spirit transcends any framework.
In case you’re wondering: in Whole Signs Astrology I’m a Gemini Sun 12th house, Scorpio Moon 5th house, Cancer AC 1st House; I’m a HD 1/3 Generator; and in Gene Keys my Life’s Work is 16.1. None of these are more powerful than I am, but damn is it fun to play in.